Comment: First of all, please note that my rating has nothing to do with the quality of drawing. I do understand that all artists have to start somewhere. That being said, I received an "ATC" that appears to have been hastily scribbled in pencil onto a thin piece of cardstock. As such the "ATC" is very flimsy; no backing was added. There is no information on the back side (no title, artist name, date, swap name - nothing). Instead there is what looks like another hastily scribbled drawing. Perhaps it was the first drawing attempt, as it is partially erased. An ATC needs to have a strong backing; it should not be flimsy. An ATC should have a nice clean back; it should not look dirty or messy. Also, artist's normally include information (such as title of the card, name of the artist, date created, and sometimes name of the swap) on the back of the card. If you are new to making ATCs feel free to contact me if you have any questions about them. If you would like to remake the card anytime in the future, I would be happy to adjust my rating accordingly. Thank you.